Song of the Day #1,549: ‘Love Minus Zero (No Limit)’ – Veronica Bianqui

This week I will present the findings of my 35-day genome project, hoping to unearth some pearls of wisdom from the data I’ve so diligently accumulated.

Rather than post songs by the same artists I’ve been discussing over the past seven weeks, I’m going to present each day’s findings alongside a YouTube video of a cute girl covering a Bob Dylan song.

I found a bunch of these clips earlier in the year, posted a few of them and stashed the rest for a rainy day. This week it’s raining genome data.

The first step in preparing my research was to rank the 35 artists I included in the study in order of preference. Rather than create a strict 1-35 list, I split the artists into five groups of seven apiece. This was the result (names within each tier are listed alphabetically):

Tier 1: Fiona Apple, Belle & Sebastian, Elvis Costello, Bob Dylan, Ben Folds, Paul Simon, Rufus Wainwright

Tier 2: The Beatles, Aimee Mann, Tift Merritt, Randy Newman, R.E.M., Ron Sexsmith, Lucinda Williams

Tier 3: Miranda Lambert, Lyle Lovett, Tom Petty, Josh Rouse, The Shins, Elliott Smith, Bruce Springsteen

Tier 4: Counting Crows, Fountains of Wayne, Billy Joel, John Mayer, Brad Paisley, Michael Penn, The Rolling Stones

Tier 5: Beck, Eminem, Shakira, The Smiths, Stew, Talking Heads, Dar Williams

All of the usual list-making caveats apply. I could listen to an album by a Tier 3 artist tomorrow and think I was nuts not to put him or her in Tier 2. But this is the arrangement I’m using for the purposes of this research.

The next step, and the one I’ll focus on for today’s post, was to see how many categories each of these artists fell into, and to look for any patterns across the tiers.

My hypothesis was that the more I like an artist (ie., the higher a tier she is in), the more genome categories she will fall into. Each tier, therefore, should have a higher ‘categories per artist’ number than the one below it.

Hypothesis confirmed, more or less.

Here are the average categories per artist for each of my five tiers:

Tier 1: 2.86
Tier 2: 2.86
Tier 3: 1.43
Tier 4: 1.43
Tier 4: 1.00

As you can see, the more I like an artist, the more likely he or she is to show up in multiple genome categories. Three of my four oddball, zero-category artists wound up in the bottom tier, while the top two tiers were dominated by those in two, three or four categories.

This is one way to answer the question that came up several times over the past seven weeks (“If you like ‘pop’ or ‘folk rock,’ why don’t you like so-and-so?”). Maybe so-and-so is just a pop or folk rock artist, while I tend to prefer artists who combine those sounds with my other categories.

So my perfect match would be a melancholy singer-songwriter who performs in folk, pop and country styles and plays the piano. Randy Newman was the closest of my 35 candidates to that ideal, though the ‘pop’ and ‘country’ designations are a bit of a stretch.

Actually, the artist who comes to mind when I read that description is Elton John. And that might be an argument for me to seek out more of his albums. I own only a few, and don’t listen to those very often — not because I don’t like them but because I’ve never taken much time to get to know them. Maybe that should be my first takeaway from the genome project.


5 thoughts on “Song of the Day #1,549: ‘Love Minus Zero (No Limit)’ – Veronica Bianqui

  1. Dana says:

    Well,in the spirit of playing your game, I would suggest that perhaps Elton lacks the folk cred to vault into your faves.

    And Beatles in tier 2 with apple and Rufus in tier 1? Wow!

  2. Clay says:

    I figured The Beatles ranking might raise some eyebrows. I didn’t base these rankings in any way on historical importance or influence… solely on who I listen to the most and whose music has the most impact on me right now.

  3. Andrea Katz says:

    If you enjoy a female voice singing
    Dylan songs, have you ever heard Joan Baez’ Any Day Now double album. Fantastic! This young woman was highly enjoyable. Thanks.

  4. Clay says:

    I have not, but I will definitely check it out. I like what I’ve heard of Baez over the years.

  5. Veronica says:

    Hey, thanks for posting my video! If you wanna hear some original music head on over to or

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s