Ella Langley’s ‘Choosin’ Texas‘ might have lost the top spot of the Hot 100 to Taylor Swift, but it’s been hanging in there at #2. In fact, Swift’s other three new songs debuted at #3-5, unable to fully dislodge the country smash.
At #3 this week is Stella Lefty’s ‘Boston,’ in its 28th week on the chart. It cracked the top 20 in June and has been kicking around the top five for more than a month, peaking at #2.
This modest country pop song has generated a ton of discourse, around both its composition and Lefty herself. Lefty is dismissed by her detractors as an “industry plant” who owes her success not to hard work and talent but to the connections of her billionaire father, Eric Lefkofsky, the co-founder of Groupon.
Lefty grew up in a wealthy Chicago suburb, attended Tulane University, studied abroad in Amsterdam, and lives in Los Angeles, a bio that doesn’t necessarily align with her preference for country music, a genre that thrives on authenticity.
I think country music has a much bigger tent these days, so I don’t fault her for not fitting the profile. As for the nepo baby charges, I acknowledge she has had opportunities most aspiring musicians never will, but at the end of the day I’m going to judge a performer on her songs, not her parents’ Wikipedia page.
As for the song, the big controversy around ‘Boston’ is that its chorus bears a striking similarity to the verses of Noah Kahan’s ‘Stick Season.’ Lefty claims she hadn’t considered Kahan’s song at all while writing hers, though multiple old videos of her performing ‘Stick Season’ in her bedroom suggest otherwise.
Kahan’s publishers chimed in before ‘Boston’ was even officially released, and he received songwriting credit on the track.
Lefty has gone on to release a few more tracks that have been compared to other popular songs, giving her a reputation as a plagiarist (she was even parodied on a recent episode of Saturday Night Live).
What the Kids are Listening To
Check out the archive of a middle aged man trying to stay relevant.
On a train back to Boston and we’re jumpin’ the gun
And I’m tellin’ you, baby, “This the part where I’d run”
But I like it when you’re nice
Like it when you’re nice to me
[Verse 1]
Well, there I was
Swearin’ I would never fall in love
All my inhibitions walked out the second
You said, “What’s up?”
So, here we go
I’m throwin’ out the things I used to know
I hate to admit it, but I guess I’m not better alone
[Chorus]
On a train back to Boston and we’re jumpin’ the gun
And I’m tellin’ you, baby, “This the part wherе I’d run”
But I like it when you’re nicе
Like it when you’re nice to me
[Post-Chorus]
I don’t know where it’s goin’ but don’t wanna go back
And usually I’d leave right at the thought of that
But I like it when you’re nice
Like it when you’re nice to me
[Verse 2]
Wakin’ up by your side
I see it when the mornin’ hits your eyes
You don’t want me to leave
Never knew I would be this along for the ride
Last month, you were just another someone
But now, we’re headin’ back to where you come from
[Chorus]
On a train back to Boston and we’re jumpin’ the gun
And I’m tellin’ you baby, “This the part where I’d run”
But I like it when you’re nice
Like it when you’re nice to me
[Post-Chorus]
I don’t know where it’s goin’ but don’t wanna go back
And usually I’d leave right at the thought of that
But I like it when you’re nice
Like it when you’re nice to me
[Bridge]
I like it when you’re nice to me
I like it when you’re nice to me
[Chorus]
On a train back to Boston and we’re jumpin’ the gun
And I’m tellin’ you, baby, “This the part where I’d run”
But I like it when you’re nice
Like it when you’re nice to me
i don’t buy the argument that her family money or connections was a major factor in her success. There are lots of musician nepo-babies who have not broken through and couldn’t buy a hit to save their lives.
Now, the fact that this song borrows heavily from ‘Stick Season’ I’m sure gave it a boost, but Olivia Rodrigo owes much of her commercial success from liberally borrowing from Paramore and Taylor Swift. After all, imitation is the highest form of flattery and a well-worn path to commercial success.
It’s a bit different in that Lefty’s breakthrough song (not to mention the few she has released since) is so heavily copied. Rodrigo made her name on the smash success of ‘Drivers License,’ which didn’t have the Swift or Paramore connections, nor did the rest of the songs on her very popular debut album.
Let’s see what Lefty’s output looks like once she releases a full album. Maybe this will be a hiccup, or maybe she won’t be able to shake the reputation.
It’s a perfectly pleasant song that has the good benefit of riding the female country wave that is clearly sweeping the charts right now. I do think she was likely afforded a much easier connection to access fame and success through her upbringing and I won’t immediately discount her for that. I”m sure her looks are another contributing factor, but that’s all a part of the age old recipe towards becoming a “star”!
As you said, I’d be interested to see what a full album and more songs from Lefty would sound like, but right now there’s not too much interesting about her music although it’s got a nice folky ring to it!
It’s funny how talent springs up without regard for, well, anything – and maybe in places some of us would prefer it not? Regarding “middle age” relevancy, don’t think M. Montauk need justify any of his efforts!
Interesting that I had never heard her name before the other night when I searched for the song (My Kinda Love) that was ending an episode in the latest season of Nobody Wants This and saw it was written by a Lefty something or other and added it to my playlist.
Only when Dana mentioned your post the next morning did I go back to see it was indeed this same artist (with multiple co-writers on the track I liked!)
I appreciate what Gracie Abram’s said about being born into privilege that enables pursuing such musical ambitions to be a reasonable career path, with lots of opportunities to enhance your natural talents along the way. After that, nepo baby or not, it’s a whole lot of luck.
A whole lot of luck and some beautiful teeth 😊