Song of the Day #6,689: ‘What’s the Matter Here?’ – In My Tribe

Continuing a countdown of my favorite albums of 1987…

#5 – In My Tribe – 10,000 Maniacs

This is one of only two albums on this list that I listened to when it first came out. My sister was introduced to 10,000 Maniacs by a co-worker at her video store job, and I listened to In My Tribe through her before adopting it for myself.

I think of 10,000 Maniacs as an Athens, Georgia, band, and I think of In My Tribe as their debut album. Neither is the case. The alt-rock outfit formed in Jamestown, New York, and released its first two albums in 1983 and 1985 before breaking through with this one.

They did move to Atlanta for a spell before relocating to New York, and they played several shows in Athens (sometimes in support of R.E.M.).

In My Tribe was the band’s first album without founding guitarist/songwriter John Lombardo, and his departure allowed lyricist/lead singer Natalie Merchant to collaborate with other band members. No disrespect to Lombardo, but the result was a stellar batch of songs that led to major success and a Double Platinum record.

Many of the songs tackle social issues, from child abuse and alcoholism to illiteracy and the military industrial complex. Merchant’s soulful vocals and thoughtful lyrics keep those tracks from descending into parody — they make up some of the album’s best material (case in point, today’s SOTD).

Other standouts include the jaunty ‘Like the Weather,’ the expansive ‘The Painted Desert,’ and the gorgeous album closer, ‘Verdi Cries.’

In My Tribe initially featured a cover of Cat Stevens’ ‘Peace Train’ (it was the second single, in fact) but it was removed from later editions after Stevens’ controversial comments about author Salman Rushdie. A bit of an overreaction, in my opinion.

[Verse 1]
That young boy without a name
Anywhere I’d know his face
In this city, the kid’s my favorite
I’ve seen him, seen him
I see him every day

[Verse 2]
I’ve seen him run outside
Looking for a place to hide
From his father, the kid half-naked
And I said to myself
“Oh, what’s the matter here?”

[Chorus]
I’m tired of the excuses everybody uses
He’s their kid, I stay out of it
But who gave you the right to do this?

[Verse 3]
We live on Morgan Street
Just ten feet between and his mother
I never see her, but her screams and cussing
I hear them every day

[Verse 4]
Threats like, “If you don’t mind
I will beat on your behind
Slap you
Slap you silly,” made me say, “Hey, hey, hey
Oh, what’s the matter here?”

[Chorus]
I’m tired of the excuses everybody uses
He’s your kid, do as you see as you see fit
But get this through that I don’t approve
Of what you did to your own flesh and blood

[Instrumental]

[Chorus]
I have heard the excuses everybody uses
He’s your kid, do as you see fit
But get this through that I don’t approve
Of what you did to your own flesh and blood

[Bridge]
“If you don’t sit in your chair straight
I’ll take this belt from around my waist
And don’t you think that I won’t use it!”

[Chorus]
Answer me and take your time
What could be the awful crime
He could do at so young an age?

If I’m the only witness to your madness
Offer me some words to balance out
What I see and what I hear

All these cold and rude things that you do
I suppose you do because he belongs to you
And instead of love and the feel of warmth
You’ve given him these cuts and sores
That don’t heal with time or with age

[Outro]
And I want
To say yeah
Want to say hey, hey, hey, yeah
“What’s the matter here?”

But I don’t dare say hey, hey, yeah
“What’s the matter here?”

But I don’t dare say hey, hey

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.