The next inductee into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Class of 2011 is singer-songwriter Neil Diamond.
Diamond was first eligible for the Hall in 1989 but went unnominated until the year he got in. At least he made it on his first ballot, though I’d argue it was a couple of decades late. Say what you will about Diamond — bemoan his corniness and the schlocky quality of some of his material — but the man is a beloved hitmaker whose songs have been performed by artists of all genres.
Diamond has written and recorded ten #1 hits and landed 28 others in the top ten. His ‘Sweet Caroline’ is performed regularly, with full audience participation, in sports arenas and bars all over the world.
And while some of those songs are suspect (I certainly won’t mount a defense for ‘Heartlight’ anytime soon), many others are downright cool. There’s a reason Quentin Tarantino, one of our hippest filmmakers, has used his work in more than one movie.
Diamond retired from touring in 2018 after being diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. In 2021, a jukebox musical based on his life titled A Beautiful Noise opened on Broadway. Now 84, he is a living legend more than worthy of the Hall of Fame.
Baby, something’s wrong
Oh no, no, no, no
That old time fire is gone
It’s not so much things that you say, love
It’s what you don’t say I am afraid of
I got the feelin’
I’m hearin’ goodbye
Don’t have to say it
It’s there in your eyes
Oh why, oh my
Oh no, no, no, no
You don’t smile the same
Oh no, no, no, no
Like you been hidin’ pain
I love you so much, I could taste it
But girl, your eyes tell me it’s wasted
I got the feelin’
I’m hearin’ goodbye
Don’t have to say it
It’s there in your eyes
Oh why, oh my
Oh no, oh no
Oh no, no
Oh no, baby
I got the feelin’
I’m hearin’ goodbye
I got the feelin’
That I’m gonna die
I recall years ago hearing Bob Costas interviewing Bruce Springsteen where Costas was arguing that Diamond’s early work such as “Forever in Blue Jeans” was great, and then he turned to schmaltz. As I recall, Bruce was not even willing to say the early songs were great. Anyway, I’m sure it was the opinion of the likes of Bruce that kept Diamond out of the Rock Hall for many years – and defenders like Costas who eventually let him in.
He certainly belongs in the Rock Hall!