Most of my favorite musical movie moments come from movies in my top 10 or top 20, but every year I seem to come across at least one standout moment from a movie that’s otherwise forgettable.

Last year it was Jenny Slate’s sublime performance of ‘Suddenly Seymour‘ in the streaming romcom I Want You Back. This year it’s a scene from the Jennifer Lawrence sex comedy No Hard Feelings.

Lawrence’s character has been enlisted to get a shy young man (Andrew Barth Feldman) out of his shell before he heads to college. The kid’s parents encourage her to “date” him, using every connotation of that word you can imagine, in exchange for a new car.

Of course, what starts as a mercenary effort soon morphs into something more tender, as Lawrence gets to know the young man better. At one point, they bond over his misreading of the Hall & Oates song ‘Maneater’ (he thinks it’s about a monster).

Later, during a dinner scene, she encourages him to play the piano and when he finally agrees, a slowed-down version of ‘Maneater’ is his song of choice. Feldman nails it, as does Lawrence, whose silent reaction to the performance is just as gripping as the song.