Ben Folds Five – Ben Folds Five (1995)
This pick will come as no surprise to regular readers of the blog. I’ve gone on record calling this my favorite album and even featured it in its entirety a year and a half ago.
In fact, I’ve had to cheat in order to post a song today. This recording of ‘Alice Childress’ isn’t from the album itself but from a live radio performance by the band on KCRW. Fittingly, given yesterday’s featured album, Folds writes in the liner notes that he sang this song “absolutely intimidated by Fiona Apple’s performance on the same show.”
Ben Folds Five’s debut doesn’t have any of the thematic unity or dramatic production work that separates other albums in my 90’s top five. It sounds very much like what it is — a garage rock record banged out with no frills in record time. Just Folds on piano, Robert Sledge on bass, Darren Jesse on drums and microphones to capture all the wonderful noise they created.
This record bursts with creative energy and peerless musicianship. It captures the electricity of three musical savants in perfect sync fulfilling a shared vision. Folds wrote all of these songs but the contributions of Sledge and Jesse are essential, their intricate bass and drum parts as integral to each song’s success as the lead piano.
But of course, as always, it boils down to the songs. And Folds — right out of the gate — crafted some of the finest tunes of his career for this record. From sweetly sad ballads like ‘Boxing’ and today’s SOTD to the hilarious ‘Uncle Walter’ and ‘Underground’ and the epic showmanship of ‘Philosophy’ and ‘The Last Polka.’
Every song here is both perfect on its own and a perfect piece of the whole. To my ear, the album doesn’t contain a single misstep or wrong note — not musically, and not in the journey on which it takes the listener.
Nineteen other albums on this list might fall in a different position if I ran through this process again, but Ben Folds Five was cemented at the top spot before I even started.
I walk on down the hill and maybe buy a beer
I think about my friends
Sometimes I wish they lived out here
But they wouldn’t dig this town
No they wouldn’t dig this town
Try not to think about it
Alice Childress
Try not to think about it anymore
Try not to think about it
Alice Childress
Anymore, no not anymore
Alice, the world
Is full of ugly things
That you can’t change
Pretend it’s not that way
That’s my idea of faith
You can blow it off
And say there’s good
In nearly everyone
Just give them all a chance
Give them all a chance
CHORUS
No it didn’t work out
No it didn’t work out
The way we thought it would
No it didn’t work out
An arranged marriage is not so good
Thank God it’s you
You know your timing is impeccable
I’m not fooling you
I don’t know what to do
some dude just knocked me cold
And left me on the sidewalk
Took everything I had
Everything I had
Try not to thing about it
Alice Childress
Try not to think about it anymore
It’s getting late where you are
Alice Childress
Anymore, no not anymore

Definitely no surprise here, and a well deserved placement atop your list.
I love how unapologetic you are about this album’s “cemented” place at the top of your list. Listening to this version of one of my very favorite songs, it’s difficult to argue with your selection. While I might have similar reasons – uneasy to articulate – for choosing another album as #1, I would never quibble with the choice of this song in particular as a best of anything… I have always had a passion for this song I don’t even understand (though I believe I may have wrestled with trying to articulate it earlier on this blog). Regardless, it’s something special.