Elvis Costello has collaborated with a boatload of artists over the years. He’s written songs with Paul McCartney, Aimee Mann, Burt Bacharach and Loretta Lynn, to name a few. A few years back, he wrote a song with Kris Kristofferson and Rosanne Cash and the trio planned to cut an album together, though that didn’t come to pass (at least not yet).
I like that an artist as prolific and excellent as Costello makes the time to write with other musicians. He clearly doesn’t need to do it. His muse is on speed, he could write original material from now until the day he dies. But he must get something out of these collaborations — even if it’s just the pleasure of sharing a room with somebody whose work he admires.
Costello penned another track with Rosanne Cash that wound up on Momofuku. Its working title was, appropriately enough, ‘Song With Rose,’ and he liked that well enough to leave it in place on the album.
I’ve always wanted to be a fly on the wall during a collaborative songwriting session. I assume they’re all very different, from the ‘two rooms’ method of Elton John and Bernie Taupin (and Ben Folds and Nick Hornby) to the ‘jam until you come up with a song’ method of many bands.
Reading the lyrics to ‘Song With Rose,’ they sound very much like Costello’s words. Did Cash write the music? Did the inspiration for this track come to them together or separately? Why don’t they put out behind the scenes clips and commentary tracks on CDs the way they do on DVDs?
The days dragged on like cigarettes
In the distance martyrs and martinets
Dally, dancing with the empty silhouettes of threats
So, where but heaven does love end
And where on earth does it begin
It’s not the kind of love that is pinned
Like a medal
Or presses pennies in a tin
There is hope, and after that, there is only faith
Love like a wraith
Never made me afraid
Consoled as I was by that shade…
Here lie the roses in the ashes
Deep as the barnacles that cling
Just like a lace that runs through everyone and everything
In that other still forever
In that time before the past
I told myself we’d be together
Can you promise me that it will be eternally?
There is hope, and after that, there is only faith
Love like a wraith
Never made me afraid
Consoled as I was
Consoled as I was
Consoled as I was by that shade…
I suspect you are right that Cash’s primary contribution to this was the music, although I hear some of Elvis’ signature musical twists in there as well.
I think that, in most of Elvis’ collaborations, he takes the lead with lyrics and allows the musical style to flow from his collaborator. He certainly did that with Bacharach, and also McCartney, although, in the latter case, I think Elvis first let Paul come up with a melody line, and then Elvis twisted it (as I think he did here).
Anyway, another good track from this fine album.